Career decisions

7 min read

Should I step down from management?

Compare two moments from your working week, check the pay and duties of a specialist role, and try one piece of hands-on work before you decide.

First published · Last edited

A woman at a desk between two paths lined with trees

Pick two moments from last week. Maybe you helped a teammate get past a problem on Tuesday and fixed a tricky one yourself on Friday. Which would you make room for again? If you keep choosing the hands-on work, a role without direct reports is worth trying. If what you'd happily drop is the status meeting, start there. Our guide to career astrology for managers and team leads has more questions about how you work.

What would actually change?

Hands arranging a red lanyard beside a notebook and pencil

In a specialist role, you take responsibility for a piece of work. Someone else handles the team's performance reviews, hiring and day-to-day support. You may still teach a colleague or lead a project.

Ask who would take over your current duties. An offer to do both jobs deserves a closer look, especially if the hours stay the same.

Imagine handing over your next round of reviews. What would you like to put in that time?

Find out whether your employer has a role at your level with that kind of work. You can explore another team if yours has no opening.

Compare staying with stepping down

Read across each row with a recent week in mind. One answer can matter more to you than all the others combined.

QuestionA reason to stayA reason to explore a moveSomething to try
EnergyYou enjoy helping someone get unstuck.You miss solving problems yourself.Keep two weeks of task notes.
DirectionYou want to coach a bigger team.You want to get better at a craft.Describe a good day two years from now.
TimingOne difficult project fills your calendar.You miss the work even in quieter weeks.Pick a date to look again.
Pay and titleYour current package meets a need.A different title could suit you if the pay works.Ask for the salary range and level.
A way backYou want a return option and have no details yet.You know what would happen after a trial.Ask who decides and on what date.

What gives you energy?

Hiring, giving feedback and settling a disagreement all count as work. After a one-to-one, write down what you enjoyed or would gladly hand over. Do the same after an hour spent making something.

Which skill do you want to build?

Picture someone asking for your help two years from now. Would you like the question to be about coaching a new colleague, or about a tricky part of the work itself? Your answer can include both.

What do the pay and title mean to you?

Ask for the salary range, bonus terms and title of the actual job. Compare them with what you have now. A title can matter to you even if the numbers work.

Is this the right time?

Look at a busy week and a quieter one. Did you want the same change in both? Our guide to making a career decision can help you weigh competing priorities. Ask separately what it would take to manage a team again.

For the next two weeks, note one task you wanted more time for and one you would drop. Add what was happening that day.

Try the work before you decide

A person in a red sweater walking across a wooden bridge

A short trial can answer questions a job description leaves open. Agree on what comes off your plate before you add anything.

  1. Spend a day beside someone in the role. Ask to see the routine work as well as the interesting problems.
  2. Take on one small project from start to finish. Notice which parts you want to repeat.
  3. Ask your manager what a trial could cover, who would support the team and whether a permanent role exists.
  4. Book a review date together. Bring your notes and decide whether to continue, adjust the trial or stop.

Imagine a software team lead who misses building features. She offers to finish one small feature while a colleague covers an agreed part of her team duties. At the review, she can ask herself which she missed more: working on the feature or helping the team solve it.

Four doubts about leaving management

An open book beneath a red desk lamp

Does it mean I failed?

You may have learned exactly which part of managing you enjoy. Name something you did well and something you'd rather spend less time on. Both belong in the conversation.

Could I manage a team again?

Ask how someone would apply for a future opening. A return to your old job and the chance to apply for another one are different offers.

Would I earn less?

Ask for the figures for the specific role. Check your base pay, bonus and next salary review before deciding what you can afford.

Can a good manager prefer other work?

Think of a conversation you handled well. Would you want three more like it next week? Skill and appetite are two different questions.

Take the doubt that matters most to you to someone who can answer it for this particular job.

How a career reading can help

You can use a career reading to think about direction, work rhythm, money and timing. For example, what length of uninterrupted time lets you finish something you care about?

If your birth time is unknown, the chart uses noon as a reference. Treat details that depend on the hour, including the rising sign, as approximate. A chart can't tell you what a job pays or how much you'll enjoy it.

Compare one prompt with your calendar. Where does it fit, and where does your week tell a different story?

What to try this week

A sheet of paper beside a red coffee cup and a plant

Choose whichever of these answers the question you still have.

  • Keep the two-week task log. A few words beside a calendar entry are enough.
  • Describe the work you want in two years. Include one ordinary responsibility you'd be glad to keep.
  • Ask a trusted colleague in a specialist role what takes up more time than they expected.

If your next meeting is a one-to-one, leave a minute afterwards to note which part you'd do again.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I step down from a management position?

Ask your manager or HR whether a suitable role is open and how you'd apply. Find out who would cover your team and when a move could happen.

How do I explain the move in an interview?

Pick an example that is true for you. Describe a piece of work you enjoyed, what managing taught you about doing it with others, and why you want to spend more time on it in this job.

What are seven things leaders should stop doing?

Look for these seven habits: rewriting finished work, answering every question yourself, cancelling one-to-ones, saving feedback for annual reviews, changing priorities without explaining why, booking meetings without a decision to make, and taking credit for someone else's idea. Pick one and ask a colleague when they last saw it.

Show more questions

Could stepping down hurt my career?

Look at what the move would let you learn and what it would put on hold. Ask how promotion works in the proposed role and whether the next level includes work you want.

How long should I give it?

Two weeks of notes can give you a starting point. If the whole fortnight was spent fixing one urgent problem, include a more typical week before you decide.

Your next step

Circle one thing from last week you'd choose to do again, even if it's a team conversation you thought you'd want to give up. For another question to take back to that moment, try the free reading. Read my chart for free

Want the next post when it's out? Follow by RSS

Keep reading

Read these next

Short reads that pick up where this one stopped.

Browse guides